Fiberglass, Steel, Wood & Iron Doors: Which Is Best for You?


Choosing the right front door isn't just about security—it's about style, efficiency, and making a statement that fits your home’s personality. Whether you're updating your entryway or building a new home, selecting the best material for your front door is key. Each option—fiberglass, steel, wood, and iron—offers a unique blend of benefits and aesthetic appeal.
Fiberglass Doors: Low Maintenance, High Style
Best for: Busy homeowners who want durability without the upkeep.
Fiberglass doors are a favorite for a reason—they offer the look of real wood without the maintenance. Designed to withstand Arizona’s dry heat and changing temperatures, fiberglass won’t warp, crack, or dent easily. They're also energy-efficient, with excellent insulation properties to help lower your utility bills.
Pros:
- Low maintenance
- Energy-efficient
- Durable against extreme weather
- Can mimic the look of wood grain
- Doesn’t dent or rust like metal
Cons:
- Slightly more expensive than steel
- Can look artificial if not high-quality
Style tip: Choose a stained woodgrain finish for a high-end look without the wood upkeep.
Steel Doors: Security Meets Affordability
Best for: Homeowners focused on security and budget-friendly upgrades.
Steel entry doors offer top-tier security at a reasonable price point. With a solid construction and foam core for insulation, steel doors are heavier and more resistant to forced entry than some other materials. They’re also easy to paint and customize.
Pros:
- Strong and secure
- Great insulation value
- Cost-effective
- Fire-resistant
- Smooth surface for painting
Cons:
- Prone to dents and scratches
- May rust if not properly maintained
- Can absorb heat from direct sunlight
Style tip: Opt for a textured steel door with decorative glass inserts to soften the industrial feel.
Wood Doors: Classic Beauty and Warmth
Best for: Traditional homes and homeowners who love a natural, timeless look.
There’s nothing quite like a solid wood door. Rich in character and endlessly customizable, wood doors make a statement. They’re ideal for classic, rustic, or craftsman-style homes—but they do require a little TLC to keep them looking their best.
Pros:
- Naturally beautiful and unique
- Customizable with stains, carvings, and panels
- Heavier feels offers a luxury touch
- Good insulation when properly sealed
Cons:
- Requires regular maintenance
- Susceptible to warping, cracking, and fading
- Typically more expensive
Style tip: Wood works beautifully for covered entryways or porches to minimize exposure to weather.
Iron Doors: Bold, Artistic, and Secure
Best for: Luxury homes or those wanting maximum impact and security.
Iron doors are showstoppers. They're strong, incredibly durable, and offer unmatched visual appeal—especially with ornate scrollwork or glass panels. While they tend to be heavier and more expensive, they provide elite security and a truly custom aesthetic.
Pros:
- Exceptional strength and durability
- Custom designs and finishes
- Boosts curb appeal
- Adds value to high-end homes
- Fire- and weather-resistant
Cons:
- Expensive
- Requires professional installation
- Can be prone to rust if not properly coated
Style tip: Consider a wrought iron door with frosted glass for elegance and privacy combined.
How to Choose the Right Door for Your Home
When comparing entry door materials, think about more than just looks. Here are a few things to consider:
1. Climate Conditions
In Arizona, heat and sun exposure can be tough on wood and metal. Fiberglass and well-treated steel are excellent for resisting temperature changes.
2. Maintenance Level
Love the look of wood but hate the upkeep? Fiberglass might be your ideal alternative.
3. Security Needs
Steel and iron are the most secure, but a solid-core fiberglass or wood door with strong locks can still do the job well.
4. Budget
Steel is the most budget-friendly, followed by fiberglass. Wood and iron offer the most luxury and customization, but at a higher price point.
5. Home Style and Personality
Your front door should complement your home’s architecture and your design preferences.
- Traditional homes: Wood or wood-look fiberglass
- Modern homes: Smooth steel or minimalist iron
- Mediterranean or Southwestern: Ornate iron or rustic wood
- Contemporary ranch: Fiberglass with clean lines
Shop Entry Doors at The Window Depot
No matter your style or budget, The Window Depot has the right entry door for you. We offer a wide selection of fiberglass, steel, wood, and iron doors from trusted manufacturers—and we’re happy to help you find one that fits your home’s character and your needs.